Google

Friday, November 19, 2004

Motions from the Northeast Asian Championship (Held sometime in Nov 2004, I think)

This tournament followed the Asians format - 3 motions per round, the teams decide on the motion to be debated. The Northeast Asian Championships is targeted mainly at Korean and Japanese universities (I think). Given the shortness of debating history in that region, it's quite no surprise that these are very classic motions, it seems (at least to me).

Round: Practice
1. THW allow condom vending machines in schools.
2. THS minimum quotas for women in Asian politics.
3. THW cancel 3rd world debt.

Round 1: China
1. THW not support internet censorship in China.
2. THBT we need another military superpower.
3. TH supports the 3 Gorges Dam (I am quite clueless about this).

Round 2: Sports
1. THW permit performance enhancing drugs at the Olympics.
2. THW ban all fighting sports.
3. THW equalize prize money for male and female athletes.

Round 3: Law and Order
1. THW legalize prostitution.
2. THW punish government corruption with the death penalty.
3. THW protect whistleblowers.

Round 4: Science
1. THW ban genetically modified food.
2. THB that space exploration is a waste.
3. THW prohibit human cloning.

Round 5: Terrorism
1. THBT the US led War on Terror has made the world less safe.
2. THB that Putin should talk not shoot.
3. THW grant immediate statehood to Palestine.

Round 6: Human Rights
1. THB that child labour is justified.
2. THW legalize gay marriage.
3. THBT pharmaceutical patents should not be enforced in Africa.

Round 7: Religion
1. THB that China should not restrict religious freedom.
2. THBT the churches should allow gay clergy.
3. THW include religious teaching in public schools.

Quarters: Energy
1. THBT the Kyoto protocol needs US ratification.
2. THW build nuclear power plants.
3. THW provide public transportation for free.

Semis: Northeast Asia - Economics
1. THW protect local film industries through screenquotas.
2. THW relocate the capital of Korea.
3. THW support a free trade zone in Northeast Asia.

Finals: Northeast Asia - Military
1. THW withdraw South Korean troops from Iraq.
2. THB that North Korea has the right to develop nuclear weapons.
3. THB that US bases should get out of Northeast Asia.

Source: YahooGroups E-mail from Jason Jarvis, Lecturer at Kyung Hee University.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home